Beyond Rankings: How to Measure Your Website’s Visibility in the Age of Generative Search

Why I Started jonmonk.ai: Exploring Website Optimisation in an AI-Driven World

26/05/2025

Why This Blog Exists And Who It’s For – Event Marketing Strategy

17/08/2025

1. Introduction: Why Rankings Are No Longer Enough

The search landscape is shifting beneath our feet.

For decades, measuring your website's visibility was straightforward. Check your Google rankings, celebrate if you hit page one, and job done. But the game has changed dramatically with AI-powered tools like ChatGPT, Google's Search Generative Experience (SGE), Bing Chat, and Perplexity AI reshaping how people find information.

These platforms don't serve up the familiar list of "10 blue links" we're used to. Instead, they craft direct answers by pulling together information from across the web. Your content might inform their response without sending a single visitor to your site.

So when there are no traditional rankings to track, what should marketers and SEO professionals be monitoring instead? This shift towards Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) demands entirely new ways of measuring success.

Let's explore how to navigate this new landscape.

2. What Is Generative Search (and Why Should You Care)?

Generative search relies on AI models that grasp natural language and deliver complete answers rather than directing users elsewhere.

The key players include:

ChatGPT by OpenAI: https://chat.openai.com/
Bing Chat (powered by GPT-4): https://www.bing.com/chat
Perplexity AI: https://www.perplexity.ai/
Google Search Generative Experience (SGE): https://blog.google/products/search/generative-ai-search-updates/

These tools have become essential resources for information seekers. The catch? Your brand might feature prominently in their responses without you realising it or receiving proper recognition.

When your content informs an answer but generates no clicks, are you truly visible to your audience?

3. The Big Shift: From Clicks and Rankings to Mentions and Authority

Traditional SEO was beautifully simple: rank highly, drive traffic, measure conversions.

Generative AI has turned this model on its head:

Rankings don't exist in the traditional sense: Your content either influences the AI's response or it doesn't.
Zero-click answers are the goal: Users get what they need without visiting your website.
Being mentioned trumps being clicked: When AI quotes or references your content, it builds trust and authority even without referral traffic.

Think of it this way

Traditional search is like competing for prime window space in a busy shopping street. Generative search is about becoming the trusted expert that the shopkeeper quotes when customers ask for advice.

4. How Do You Know If You're Being Mentioned in Generative Answers?

The most straightforward approach is to interrogate the AI tools directly:

Test your key queries in Google SGE (where available).
Ask ChatGPT or Claude about your topics or brand.
Run your target keywords through Perplexity.ai and see which sources get cited.

Monitor Referral Traffic

Some platforms do provide referral data:

Watch for unusual query strings from search.google.com in Google Analytics.
Filter your GA4 traffic for referrers like www.bing.com containing chat query parameters.

Available Tools

SGE.dev (alerts when your site appears in Google's AI overviews): https://sge.dev/
Thruuu.com (identifies whether AI overviews trigger for specific keywords): https://www.thruuu.com/
Writesonic AI Analytics (monitors when AI systems crawl or cite your content): https://writesonic.com/ai-traffic-analytics

5. New Metrics for Measuring Visibility in the AI Era

Here are the essential GEO metrics that are replacing traditional rankings:

Inclusion Rate - How frequently does your content appear in AI-generated responses to relevant queries?

Citation Count - Is your brand, article, or product specifically named or linked within the response?

Prominence - Are you positioned as the primary source, or merely listed among many citations?

Referral Traffic - Do users actually click through from generative answers to your website?

Brand Search Volume - Are more people searching for your brand after encountering it in AI responses?

SEO Geek Corner

Technical tracking opportunities include: Referrals from search.google.com with _sg parameters (indicating SGE clicks). Bing Chat traffic identifiable by extended query parameter strings. Upticks in brand and product searches visible in Google Search Console. Featured snippet gains or losses as proxies for SGE inclusion.

6. How to Optimise Your Content for AI Visibility

To maximise your chances of being selected by generative AI

Answer questions directly - Structure content with clear headings and concise, informative paragraphs.
Embrace FAQ and How-To formats - AI systems favour these formats for summarisation purposes.
Maintain content quality and currency - AI models prefer referencing current, authoritative content.
Implement structured data - FAQ schema, HowTo schema, and Article schema help AI systems better understand your content.

SEO Geek Corner

To maximise your chances of being selected by generative AI Answer questions directly - Structure content with clear headings and concise, informative paragraphs. Embrace FAQ and How-To formats - AI systems favour these formats for summarisation purposes. Maintain content quality and currency - AI models prefer referencing current, authoritative content. Implement structured data - FAQ schema, HowTo schema, and Article schema help AI systems better understand your content. SEO Geek Corner Use AlsoAsked to discover related questions worth addressing. Monitor your AI inclusion rates weekly to track performance. Consider testing different content approaches to improve AI uptake rates.

7. Available Tools (and What's on the Horizon)

Current GEO Monitoring Tools

SGE.dev – Notifications when your site features in Google's SGE: https://sge.dev/
Thruuu – Identifies AI Overview triggers: https://www.thruuu.com/
Writesonic AI Tracker – Monitors AI visits and citations: https://writesonic.com/ai-traffic-analytics
Goodie.ai – Enterprise-level GEO monitoring covering mentions, traffic, and prominence: https://goodie.ai/

What's Coming

Google may introduce AI Overview metrics within Search Console.
Bing could release analytics specifically for Bing Chat citations.
AI crawlers will become increasingly recognisable in server logs and analytics platforms.

8. Conclusion: Start Measuring What Actually Matters

Traditional SEO isn't disappearing, but it's certainly evolving. If you're only tracking rankings, you're overlooking a significant portion of your visibility.

Generative Engine Optimisation centres on becoming the source AI chooses to represent your expertise. This means creating quotable content, monitoring your inclusion rates, and staying ahead of industry developments.

The time to start is now. Begin testing, start tracking, because if your content isn't appearing in AI responses, your audience might never discover you.